2

I have a gas water heater. If I go out of town for a week during warm months, I've been told that I will save energy if I turn the heater off before I leave.

Would that still be true if I was going to be gone for 3 days? How about 1 day? 12 hours? Does it depend on the water heater?

4
  • I'm not sure of whether it would be more or less efficient (i.e. whether heating up cold water might take more energy than simply maintaining it at temp), but another option might be to dial the temperature down while you're away, and have it only maintain the lower temperature.
    – Robotnik
    Sep 2 '20 at 0:05
  • 1
    Does it have a pilot light, or electronic ignition?
    – LShaver
    Sep 2 '20 at 0:19
  • I wouldn't bother.Depending where you are ,the minimum monthly gas charge is very likely exceeds the cost of the gas used. Sep 3 '20 at 0:19
  • @LShaver good question! Electric ignition
    – capet
    Sep 3 '20 at 23:40
1

At any given thermostat setting, for any given amount of time, it will be more efficient for your gas water heater to be turned off than to be turned on.

As described by Newton's law of cooling, the rate of heat loss of a body is proportional to the difference in temperatures between the body and its surroundings.

Newton's law of cooling

Comparing the two situations - heater on and heater off - we can disregard h (heat transfer rate, generally related to insulation of the tank), A (surface area of the device), and Tenv (temperature of the environment) as these should be roughly fixed. Thus only T (temperature of the water) will be interesting for the comparison. The greater T, the greater the heat loss, the greater the energy required by the heater.

If the heater is on, energy required is equal to energy lost which is proportional to T times the duration being measured. Notably, T is held more or less constant at its greatest value in this scenario.

If the heater is off, energy required is 0 plus the energy to return the water to the desired temperature. It should be clear that for a long enough period, the heater off situation always requires less energy because T is not even a factor.

What about for shorter durations? For the heater off scenario, the amount of energy required to return the water to the thermostat set temperature increases until the water temperature reaches the ambient temperature and then remains constant. However, since T is dropping the rate of that energy requirement increase is dropping as well. Therefore the average power (energy per time) required to re-obtain the thermostat set temperature is highest instantaneously after the heater is shut off (call it Time[0]) and ever after smaller and smaller.

But the power required to re-obtain the thermostat set temperature at Time[0] is exactly equal to the average power required by the heater on scenario for the entire time period.

Therefore shutting the heater off will always use less power, regardless of the duration.

There should be no practical matters which change this conclusion. The heat exchanger in the water heater is probably more efficient at lower water temperatures, making the heater off scenario even better. If the water heater has a gas pilot then that's more wasted energy in the heater on scenario. If it has an inefficient ignition system then that's still more benefit to the heater off scenario, which will involve fewer ignitions.

Your Answer

By clicking “Post Your Answer”, you agree to our terms of service, privacy policy and cookie policy

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.