After taking a few different "tests," I have realized that results may vary quite significantly.
Is there an online, comprehensive carbon footprint "test" that is both precise and accurate?
Sustainable Living Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for folks dedicated to a lifestyle that can be maintained indefinitely without depleting available resources. It only takes a minute to sign up.
Sign up to join this communityAfter taking a few different "tests," I have realized that results may vary quite significantly.
Is there an online, comprehensive carbon footprint "test" that is both precise and accurate?
It's not possible to accurately estimate it.
There are only approximations. There are so many uncertainties. For example:
When you use electricity, should you use average carbon intensity, or marginal carbon intensity? Each tends to vary constantly (unless you're on one of the handful of already-zero-carbon electricity grids)
What adjustment do you make for the change in congestion if you drive?
What's the CO2e multiplier for flights? (big uncertainties on that one)
What's the embedded carbon in the objects you've consumed?
Which methane-multiplier should you use - 5-year, 30-year, 100-year?
How much methane leakage should you include? (It's surprising how little we know about that)
That's why you'll get such wide variations: there are big uncertainties attached to most of the calculations.
So no, one cannot accurately estimate one's own carbon footprint. The best you can do is get a wide range of possible values, and some clues as to where it's easiest to start reducing it.
I agree with the answer given by EnergyNumbers. At best you can get a rough estimate of your carbon footprint. If you want an accurate result you would need to do a carbon footprint analysis of all products you buy, all services you use, and all activities you do, and then aggregate the results. And even then the accuracy of the end result is questionable. As EnergyNumbers also mentioned, we have to make a lot of assumptions because there are so many unknowns.
Nevertheless, there are some things you can do to get better results, or have to keep in mind when interpreting the results.
One of my favourite carbon footprint calculators is the CoolCalifornia calculator because it includes indirect emissions, shows the results for individual categories and has quite a bit of parameters. It does have it's downsides though; default settings (and probably underlying data model) are for US residents, there is no option for electric cars, and personally I do think it is a bit negative when it comes to emissions for transportation.
Alternatively, US residents can use the EPA carbon footprint calculator but it lacks (indirect) emissions from things like food, clothing and services. The nice thing however is that the EPA also provides a spreadsheet, which allows you to see all the used calculations and parameters. So if you really want to make an effort and know what you are doing, you could tweak those parameters to make results more specific for your situation (perhaps even for your country of residence if you are not a US resident).
I've read that the Carbon Story calculator is quite good as it was created to meet the principles identified in this research, but I haven't tried that one myself yet.