Skip to main content
edited tags
Link
LShaver
  • 12k
  • 6
  • 32
  • 83
Tweeted twitter.com/StackSustain/status/807103477625290752
Narrow down to Japan
Source Link
Golden Cuy
  • 851
  • 4
  • 18

What has been the greenhouse gas impact of shutting down Japanese nuclear power plants post-Fukushima?

Japan shut down virtually all nuclear power plants after the March 11, 2011 earthquake, tsunami and nuclear power plant accident, and I've heard Germany is phasing out nuclear power plants as a result of Fukushima dai-ichi as well.

What has been the greenhouse gas impact of this decision? Have people merely consumed less power, or have other forms of electricity generation increased as a result? If the latter, have they been forms of electricity that have been more greenhouse gas intensive, or less greenhouse gas intensive, than nuclear power?

For the sake of simplicity, I'm asking only about Japan's decision, not about other countries that are phasing out nuclear post-Fukushima.

(As a pre-emptive reply to any criticisms: I acknowledge that nuclear power is not sustainable as it indirectly generates greenhouse gases, and there's a limited supply of nuclear material. Also, that electricity generation and electricity usage could well have changed without the shutdown of nuclear power plants, and that the impact of Germany phasing out nuclear power may be different to the impact of Japan ceasing to use nuclear power)

What has been the greenhouse gas impact of shutting down nuclear power plants post-Fukushima?

Japan shut down virtually all nuclear power plants after the March 11, 2011 earthquake, tsunami and nuclear power plant accident, and I've heard Germany is phasing out nuclear power plants as a result of Fukushima dai-ichi as well.

What has been the greenhouse gas impact of this decision? Have people merely consumed less power, or have other forms of electricity generation increased as a result? If the latter, have they been forms of electricity that have been more greenhouse gas intensive, or less greenhouse gas intensive, than nuclear power?

(As a pre-emptive reply to any criticisms: I acknowledge that nuclear power is not sustainable as it indirectly generates greenhouse gases, and there's a limited supply of nuclear material. Also, that electricity generation and electricity usage could well have changed without the shutdown of nuclear power plants, and that the impact of Germany phasing out nuclear power may be different to the impact of Japan ceasing to use nuclear power)

What has been the greenhouse gas impact of shutting down Japanese nuclear power plants post-Fukushima?

Japan shut down virtually all nuclear power plants after the March 11, 2011 earthquake, tsunami and nuclear power plant accident.

What has been the greenhouse gas impact of this decision? Have people merely consumed less power, or have other forms of electricity generation increased as a result? If the latter, have they been forms of electricity that have been more greenhouse gas intensive, or less greenhouse gas intensive, than nuclear power?

For the sake of simplicity, I'm asking only about Japan's decision, not about other countries that are phasing out nuclear post-Fukushima.

(As a pre-emptive reply to any criticisms: I acknowledge that nuclear power is not sustainable as it indirectly generates greenhouse gases, and there's a limited supply of nuclear material. Also, that electricity generation and electricity usage could well have changed without the shutdown of nuclear power plants)

Source Link
Golden Cuy
  • 851
  • 4
  • 18

What has been the greenhouse gas impact of shutting down nuclear power plants post-Fukushima?

Japan shut down virtually all nuclear power plants after the March 11, 2011 earthquake, tsunami and nuclear power plant accident, and I've heard Germany is phasing out nuclear power plants as a result of Fukushima dai-ichi as well.

What has been the greenhouse gas impact of this decision? Have people merely consumed less power, or have other forms of electricity generation increased as a result? If the latter, have they been forms of electricity that have been more greenhouse gas intensive, or less greenhouse gas intensive, than nuclear power?

(As a pre-emptive reply to any criticisms: I acknowledge that nuclear power is not sustainable as it indirectly generates greenhouse gases, and there's a limited supply of nuclear material. Also, that electricity generation and electricity usage could well have changed without the shutdown of nuclear power plants, and that the impact of Germany phasing out nuclear power may be different to the impact of Japan ceasing to use nuclear power)